A survey commissioned by the Ministry of Urban Development (MoUD) found that no city was “healthy and clean” while 40 per cent “need immediate remedial action”. The survey covered all 423 Class-I cities (with a population of more than 100,000), representing 72 per cent of India’s urban population.
Only four cities are found to be in the category of “recovering” in terms of sanitation facilities. These are Chandigarh at the top with a score of 73.480, followed by Mysore (70.650), Surat (69.080), and the New Delhi Municipal Corporation administered area (68.265). With a score of 16.750, Churu in Rajasthan is at the bottom of the list.
The survey sparked an immediate reaction in the capital of Jammu and Kashmir, Srinagar, ranked as the fourth dirtiest city among Indian cities. A day after the results were published the Chief Minister, Mr. Omar Abdullah “directed the Srinagar Municipal Corporation and the Housing Department to put in place short, medium and long term measures for ensuring cleanliness of Srinagar city”.
Nasir Sogami, the junior minister in charge of urban development, said: “It gives us bad publicity. The problem is that our work force is inadequate and for this the government has decided to engage additional 600 sweepers for maintaining sanitation in the city.”
“We may also go for outsourcing. A proposal for this is under serious consideration of the government,” he added.
The rankings used in the MoUD survey are based on on 19 sanitation parameters such as access to community toilets, safe management of human excreta, and solid waste collection and treatment. The exercise highlighted that considerable efforts are required to improve access to community and public toilets for the urban poor and to stop open-defecation.
Four color codes have been assigned to the cities based on the points they obtained in the rating; red means the cities need ‘immediate remedial action’, black means ‘need considerable improvement’, blue means ‘recovering,’ green means ‘healthy and clean.’ A ‘healthy and green city’ would have required a score between 91 and 100.
Ratings of cities is an initiative that supports implementation of the National Urban Sanitation Policy launched in 2008, to create healthy competition among cities as each strives to earn the glory of being a Nirmal Shahar (exemplary city) on a set of ratings that will determine its sanitation and healthy living status.
MoUD introduced a new benchmarking tool and award scheme in November 2009, aiming to address poor sanitation conditions in India’s urban areas. The scheme is aligned to larger goals of the National Urban Sanitation Policy (NUSP) which seeks to mobilize governments and civil society to transform urban India into community-driven Nirmal Shahars, or totally sanitized, healthy, and livable cities and towns.
The goal of Nirmal Shahar Puraskar is to encourage cities to strive for 100 percent access to sanitation facilities to all cities and 100 percent safe disposal of all city generated waste. The rating and award is based on the premise that improved public health and environmental standards are two outcomes that cities must ensure for urban citizens. In doing so, state governments and urban areas must adopt a holistic, city-wide approach while incorporating processes that help reach outputs pertaining to goals of the NUSP.
The rating does not recognize mere inputs, hardware or expenditure incurred in urban sanitation, but assesses how these lead to achievements of intermediate milestones towards the final result of 100 percent safe disposal of wastes from the city on a sustainable basis (delivering public health and environmental outcomes and benefits to citizens).
The policy aims to ensure sustained public health and environmental outcomes for all cities by making them free of open defecation; providing adequate and properly maintained individual, community and public sanitation facilities, especially for the poor; ensuring safe and sanitary disposal of waste; altered mindsets, collective behavior change and health and hygiene practices, and re-oriented institutions that work collaboratively to achieve and sustain health and environmental benefits.
NUSP is operationalized on the basis of technical and financial assistance provided to States from the Government of India (GoI) in developing and implementing State Level Sanitation Strategies and introducing a prestigious National level Reward Scheme for Cities (Nirmal Shahar Puraskar) achieving measurable milestones in becoming sanitized, livable Nirmal Shahars.
The intention is to update the survey results annually and scale it up to cover to all 5161 urban centres.
Each year if the city improves its ratings, it will be recognized and awarded “Nirmal Shahar Puraskar”. AC Nielsen, Development Research Services Pvt. Limited (DRS) and Centre for Environment Planning and Technology are facilitating the process. While the first two agencies are consulting firms, the third is a university. The cities are divided into north, south, east and northeast, west and central, and south central.
The GoI has laid out clear steps for cities and states on how they must improve sanitation and the process they must follow before they can apply for the awards. Clearly, there has to be greater involvement, participation, and ownership from states in making their cities and urban spaces healthier and more livable.
View the full Rank of Cities on Sanitation 2009-2010
See also: PIB, Rating of Cities under the National Urban Sanitation Policy, 11 May 2010
Source: Vivek Raman, WSP, 08 Jun 2010 ; IANS / Thaindian News, 13 May 2010 ; Kashmir Observer, 13 May 2010